Business transformation stories are powerful, but some companies take the leap from “good” to “great” while others remain stuck in mediocrity.
After diving into Good to Great by Jim Collins, the clear difference lies not just in strategy, but in the core principles that define a company’s purpose and ability to endure. Understanding these principles can help businesses of all sizes make that leap.
Let’s take a closer look at the key takeaways from this book and explore how companies like Hewlett-Packard, Boeing, and even high school sports teams exemplified greatness by focusing on what really matters.
What Defines “Great” Companies?
What sets a company apart and makes it truly great? The answer is not simple, but Jim Collins and his research team provide several critical insights into what allows companies to make the jump from good to great.
Collins introduces several key concepts, each of which has proven to be foundational in the journey toward greatness. These ideas transcend industries, applying to all kinds of businesses from tech giants to small startups.
Level 5 Leadership
One of the most pivotal elements in this transition is Level 5 Leadership. Collins explains that these leaders are more than just successful managers—they embody a unique combination of personal humility and professional will.
They do not seek to boost their own egos; instead, they focus on the success of their organization as a whole. Hewlett and Packard, founders of Hewlett-Packard, exemplified this by remaining humble in their triumphs, never taking sole credit for their company’s successes.
Level 5 Leaders build companies that thrive beyond their personal leadership. These leaders care more about creating lasting greatness than basking in the glory of their achievements. In a world full of self-promotion and personal branding, this focus on humility is refreshing.
Core Ideology: Values That Endure
Another key aspect of enduring greatness is the idea of core ideology.
Collins emphasizes that great companies hold on to a set of core values that guide their decision-making process. These values extend beyond just profits; they speak to the company’s purpose and its contributions to society.
Take Merck, for example, which chose to distribute a life-saving drug for river blindness, despite the fact that the afflicted populations were impoverished and unable to pay. Merck’s core ideology, focused on helping people, drove this decision.
These companies understand that while profits are necessary for survival, they are not the ultimate goal.
True greatness comes when a company pursues a higher purpose that aligns with deeply held values. Companies like Hewlett-Packard built their success on a foundation of respect for individuals, technical contribution, and responsibility to the community—principles that outlived any single product cycle.
Preserving the Core While Stimulating Progress
While core values remain steady, it’s crucial for companies to embrace change.
Collins introduces the principle of “Preserve the Core/Stimulate Progress,” a concept that highlights the balance between holding on to core values and adapting to new challenges and innovations.
Walt Disney Company, for example, has maintained its core value of creating happiness while continuously evolving its business model, from animated films to theme parks to cruise lines.
This duality—of staying true to core values while evolving strategies—has kept Disney relevant for decades.
First Who, Then What: Getting the Right People on the Bus
Many companies focus on strategies, goals, and business plans, but Collins argues that none of that matters unless you have the right people in place first.
His principle of First Who, Then What emphasizes the importance of getting the right people on board before deciding the direction of the company. Once the right team is assembled, everything else falls into place more naturally.
This concept applies to all industries and business types. A powerful example comes from a high school cross-country team, where the head coach focused on recruiting the right athletes and building a culture of discipline. The result?
A state championship-winning team that ran with purpose, not just for individual accolades but for each other.
Confronting the Brutal Facts (Stockdale Paradox)
Facing reality is a cornerstone of greatness. In what Collins calls the Stockdale Paradox, companies must learn to confront brutal facts while maintaining unwavering faith that they will prevail in the end.
This means looking at tough situations squarely in the face and acknowledging the challenges without losing hope.
Leaders who can inspire their teams to do this not only foster resilience but also help the company avoid the pitfalls of over-optimism. This paradox allows companies to stay grounded, while pushing forward toward greatness.
The Flywheel and the Doom Loop
One of the most visual and memorable concepts in the book is the Flywheel and the contrasting Doom Loop.
Companies that go from good to great do so through small, incremental steps that build momentum over time—just like turning a heavy flywheel. With consistent effort, the wheel starts spinning faster, and soon the company reaches breakthrough performance.
On the other hand, companies that fail to achieve greatness tend to fall into the Doom Loop.
They attempt dramatic changes without the foundational groundwork, and each failure leads to further frantic changes. Instead of building momentum, they experience a cycle of disappointment and short-term fixes, ultimately stalling progress.
The Flywheel concept is incredibly relevant today. In an age where quick wins and overnight success stories dominate the business narrative, Collins reminds us that sustainable greatness comes from methodical progress.
BHAGs: Big Hairy Audacious Goals
A critical part of stimulating progress, according to Collins, is the concept of the BHAG (Big Hairy Audacious Goal).
BHAGs are ambitious, long-term goals that challenge companies to push beyond what they think is possible. The difference between a good BHAG and a bad one is understanding. Great BHAGs are set with deep knowledge of what the company can become the best at, while bad ones are driven by bravado and guesswork.
Boeing’s decision in the 1950s to build commercial jets is an iconic example of a good BHAG.
At the time, Boeing had no presence in the commercial market, but the leadership team recognized their capability in aircraft manufacturing and saw a clear path forward. Boeing’s decision to build the 707, 727, and eventually the 747 transformed them into the world leader in commercial aviation.
Why Greatness? The Search for Meaning
At its core, Good to Great is not just about achieving success; it’s about finding meaning in the work a company does.
The book repeatedly comes back to one essential question: Why greatness? The answer isn’t always about making more money or dominating an industry. Instead, it’s about creating something that matters—something that has a lasting impact.
When companies align their purpose with the values that drive them, they achieve more than financial success—they create a lasting legacy.
That’s why leaders, entrepreneurs, and teams should strive for greatness, not just as a business objective but as a way to leave a mark on the world.
Get your copy of Good to Great on Amazon and start your journey toward building something that truly lasts.